So now that I’ve got a road bike you all get to answer my stupid questions.
I was adjusting the front derailleur last night and noticed the left lever doesn’t ‘click’, so once you shift onto the big ring it just shifts off once you let go of the lever.
A popular search engine indicates that sometimes they just need a good clean out (WD-40 or similar) as the grease hardens up over time - or - they are broken and need replacing.
Has anyone encountered this before? Did a clean out do the trick or am I just wasting my time and go and buy a replacement?
Yep, quite common. Spray it to shit with degreaser. Let it sit for a bit. If you can, blast it with compressed air. Then spray a teeny bit of lube. Should work. If not, repeat. If not, still, it’s fucked.
I just did this with that Cecil Walker roadie I bought. flooded both levers with degreaser (apparently brake cleaner is best but I didn’t have any), let sit, pedaled bike & tried to shift it through the gears. then use silicon or whatever to get it all smooth again.
Yeah, $25 for an HG50, $27 for a PG850, options from corncobs to MTB wide range. Similar price to similar spec 9 speed, but the 10sp Campy / 8 speed Shimano levers are cheaper than C11 / S9.
I have no qualms about 8 speed. The new claris group means that Shimano will be supporting it for a while yet, and stuff is dirt cheap at the moment. Might even buy up a couple of cassettes and a few chains to go on with.
This whole thread reminds me of when I got my 6400 equipped roadie. I took it into a shop to get serviced as it was all out of whack and had the same shifter issue and I didn’t have any time to look at it myself.
When I picked it up they said they hadn’t been able to get the front shifter working. I was about to start looking for a new lever but thought I’d give it a WD40 myself just to make sure. The degreaser fixed it. So I took it back into the shop and told them what I’d done.
The mechanic pointed at the silicon lubricant and said they tried that with a shit load of this.
I’m not sure you should have to explain the difference between a degreaser and a lubricant to a bike mechanic.
I’ve had to explain the difference between threaded and threadless headsets and the difference in cable pull between V and sidepull flat bar levers (or more accurately why some levers give you 2 spots to put the cable end)