Coming from a road background, i don’t have much of an idea when it comes to sizing of mtb frames.
I’m 6"5’, and ride the equivalent of a 61+cm seat tube on road and track. What’s a good guide for sizing up a mountain bike frame, as I’m looking around at the moment.
Just try the difference between an L (18-20") and XL (20-22"), I reckon you will be leaning more towards an XL you monster.
More importantly though - throw your leg over a few to see what feels better, try 26 and 29ers. You will probably feel more at home on a 29er I imagine.
If I was you I wouldn’t even bother with looking at M (18) or L (20) sizes. I’d be looking at XL or even XXL, you can always put a shorter stem/wider bar to shorten the length, but for xc stuff I’d rather be stretched out a bit rather than too cramped.
I’m 5’10" on a good day and all my mtbs are Mediums and a great fit for me.
Not sure of your budget but that Ebay On One, it looks pretty old so parts for forks may be an issue and I reckon disc brakes are a must on a mtb. Look at the Planet X site and you can get a new frame (with warranty) for less than $200 (+ about 40 for shipping). With some judicious shopping and being ss you could come out with a rippa bike for not a whole lot of coin.
*interwebs sizing disclaimer- it just never works out.
Look for 21 inch upwards on the seat tube and 23-25 (horizontal) in the top tube EV, or something sized ‘XL’.
Some may disagree, but sizing is not as crucial on the mountain bikes, as you tend to run a lot more sat post, and have more stem and bar options to get the cockpit right.
In my opinion, the XL geometry on the Surly 1x1 would be a good benchmark for comparisons. I ride the Large with high bars, and I know that you run a good 3cm more on the top tube than me with the same bar height.
definitely thinking ss, or at most 1x?. The OnOne on ebay was i guess a similar setup to what I was thinking. I cant for the life of me remember what my old Demo 8 frame size was, but its pretty irrelevant as it was a DH rig.
Totally understand that its more of a what feels/fits best, but its good to get a heads up on the ballpark sizing.
yeah what he said. You’ll probably feel more at home on a big 29er. I’m 6’2 and have just stripped out a “large” KHS 29er with about a 61cm ETT in favour of an XL voodoo, but I also like to be stretched out a bit.