Yeah I reckon they’d be ok for a commute like yours/mine too Adam. I think for any significant time in the saddle before 6am and I’d need something else. Will keep researching and check some of the stores around here to see if there’s anything good enough down to about 5 then I can chuck another wool liner under it.
Ezy, I’m sure we can discuss results this over a ride soon. Once I get something I’ll do a review for others. By all means keep posting more options though.
I’ve had plenty of 6am winter rides with my Ergon and only need the merino liner around 0. You can find them at Cycle City in Fyshwick. Those Gore that Ezy posted look worth checking out too.
I got some last winter, and they seem to be okay, but not as amazing as I thought they would be. Better than the Defeet which is what I was using before hand though. Haven’t had any problems with the waterproofing / wind proofing on my 20 minute commute though. Still get cold fingers and they are a touch bulky.
another trick that is popular is running cheaper fingerless MTB gloves (the OG ground effect gloves are good for this) with a basic wool glove (not a liner) underneath. it allows you to run a thicker inner glove (+warmth) and the MTB glove givesn you some windproofing and wear protection. easy to remove as well.
pearl izumi cyclones had a good rep for a while… but ive heard the quality has decreased.
At the moment I’m leaving towards picking up a half decent spring glove, then getting a merino liner from kathmandu or paddy palin to wear underneath when it’s cold.
Any chunkier and I might as well use the pipe gloves I have for snowboarding.
Edit: tthese look pretty cool but they’re $130 on chain reaction…that’s no joke.
You’ll be fine. This is all about trying what works for you too. I have Kathmandu merino liners and they make me sweat, which is not what merino should do. But Kathmandu is pretty shit.
I’ve got a selection of gloves: some thin netti ones, some thermal fleece or whatever Trek ones, some DeFeet ones, and some Knog mtb gloves. If it’s around 10 degrees I just wear the DeFeet or Trek gloves, if it gets down to 5ish I double up the netti under the trek ones. Colder than that I wear the DeFeet under the Knogs. Or various combinations of the above. I tend to err on the “slightly too cold” side of things.
I actually went to macpac on the weekend and got a pair of merino liners for $27 normally $40 if anyone else needs a pair. Will be giving them a good test this week based on that weather forecast. Will be good to see how they go under a pair of long finger capo gloves. I’m aiming to grab a more protective mtb glove or something to go over the top this week if I can get away for a lunch break.