…beware fyxomatosis…those low quality auzzie chainrings can be turned against you as deadly ninja throwing stars by the bsnyc/rtms “elite palace guard”…
Low quality, did this guy take a look at the chainring (Shit what more would you want if you were making one yourself).
It’s all in good jest though and will make for good reading.
BSNYC: blah blah fyxo. low quality chainring blah
SNAIL: blah blah did he take at look at the chainring blah blah what more could you want
SPUD: blah blah maybe he wants less milling marks blah blah
I wonder how Campag/Shimano chainrings are manufactured?
In the past they must have been punched out of sheet, but these days, you’d expect them to be CNC machined. I know for a fact that the Sugino Zen chainrings are CNC machined.
It’s true that the Fyxo chainrings don’t have the filleting on the teeth that the Campagnolo chainrings have. But whether that affects performance, is hard to tell.
You don’t draw chainrings, that operation is for making wire (pull it through a die) or beer cans (deep/reverse drawing)
Extrusion is the reverse, where you push it through a die, think toothpaste out of a tube or bicycle rims)
Mass produced Al rings would likely be made as follows:
Produce raw Al, add elements to make desired alloy, roll billet to sheet stock, punch blank out of sheet, artificially age for strength (or after all machining)
Then the finishing would be either (1) machine teeth/ramp profiles and chain ring bolt recesses etc or (2) forge profiles and minimal finishing machining, then fit pins for road, deburr/polish/anodise/silkscreen/engrave etc.
For boutique/unusual sizes/small runs, CNC is more economical.
Regarding CU’s tooth profile/milling marks, as long as they have the correct seating & topping curve that will allow the rollers to engage properly, then the rest is all cosmetics. There’s no real need for making the teeth more pyramidal by removing material from the sides, if your chainline’s straight it’s not going to have any problems engaging.
3rd pic from the bottom, i noticed the milling marks as well. it appears that they’ve been smoothed off in all the other pictures, so i assume they don’t come like that, and it is a mid process one.